If you’re like me, you were horrified to watch that video of Clay Duke shooting up a school board meeting in Panama City, Florida. Ranting incoherently, Mr. Duke was shot by a security guard and then took his own life. Luckily no innocent people were killed.
Of course the media and blogosphere are filled with people prognosticating about why Duke did what he did. Some say he was just a sad, mentally ill man under great financial stress who just snapped. Others say he was a cold-blooded individual with a criminal record who planned to carry out a mass killing. And yet others are asking why he, a convicted felon, even had a gun to begin with and are questioning the validity of the Second Amendment. One thing’s for sure, interest groups of all stripes will use this tragic incident to point fingers, throw mud and advance their own agendas. But no matter how you slice it, what happened in Florida was terrible and disturbing.
But an article on the website infowars.com stated that we should expect more of this insane behavior as the recession wears on. “When Americans start losing everything,” they wrote, citing a trend forecaster named Gerald Celente, “They will start to lose it. “ They further stated, “As we warned back in June, we are in the early stages of a new ‘age of rage,’ which will be characterized by riots, revolutions and a widespread backlash against the economic holocaust that has been unleashed by the global elite. Unfortunately there will be many more Clay Dukes over the coming years, there will be more Americans who lose everything and decide that the best way out is simply to lose it altogether.”
That’s bullshit, scaremongering and, quite frankly, stupid.
If this doom and gloom prophecy were true Bernie Madoff would have gotten plugged with a high-powered rifle long ago, bankers hoarding capital and refusing to make loans would have been strung up on lampposts and bloody riots would have already rocked our nation. But this recession has been grinding away for two years and none of these horrors have come to pass. (Though I wouldn’t shed a tear for Bernie.) And what infowars.com forgot to mention is that when you live in a nation of 300 million people, statistics show that such crazy and violent incidents like this are bound to happen. But if you look at such tragedies with a sense of proportion you’d realize these incidents occur rarely. According to the most recent FBI statistics, the rate of violent crime in the U.S. is falling, not rising. But the with the 24 hour news cycle created by television and the internet constantly pumping these stories you’d think people are shooting up places everyday. If it bleeds it leads – but such news reports are not indicative of what’s happening in the nation as a whole.
The vast majority of Americans hurt in this economy are not engaging in acts of violence. If they did I think we would have heard about it by now. And stop demonizing people who are poor. Most people who live in poverty do not flip out and kill people. My mom grew up poor in Spanish Harlem with lots of other poor people. Most of them turned out to be hardworking and responsible citizens, not gun toting maniacs with a grudge.
The article also failed to examine American History as well. During the Great Depression, when there were no Social Security or unemployment benefits until 1935, (And SS benefits didn’t start coming until 1941) the American nation did not rend itself asunder. There were problems, yes – but no revolution. No storming of the palace gates or mass murders. The Union held together. If it didn’t we’d have never summed up the willpower and fortitude to win World War II.
The Bonus Marchers who descended on Washington in the spring and summer of 1932 were not violent – though the government used violence against them. The Civil Rights movement that agitated to change racist laws and conceptions used mostly non-violent techniques and riots like those that occurred Watts, Newark and L.A. did not result in the wholesale destruction of America. This nation is much stronger than we give it credit for. And no matter what you think about the War on Terror, if America was in such sad shape would hundreds of thousands of American men and women be willing to fight and die for us on far-flung battlefields in Iraq and Afghanistan? Probably not. As our President recently said, “Don’t bet against America.” No matter what your political leanings are, we can all get behind that statement.
But fear is a nice cottage industry. Fear helps companies hustle gold futures, newspapers, survival supplies, guns and breeds all types of scams designed to separate you from your money. Just look these fly by night outfits offering to help settle your debts or salvage your mortgage while walking off with fat fees and not helping you in the least. There’s a lot of money to be made in scaring the shit of people. Don’t fall for it. We are not all going to lose our shit, no matter how much people like to tell you it will be so.
FDR once said, “We have nothing to fear but fear itself.” More recently Jon Stewart said, “We live in hard times. Not end times.” Let’s stop talking like it’s the end of the world. It isn’t. What Mr. Clay did was horrible but it’s not a harbinger of impending Armageddon. But the best response I’ve ever read regarding scaremongering eschatology was written over two thousand years ago.
“Take heed that no man deceive you….ye shall hear of wars and rumors of wars: see that ye be not troubled: for all these things must come to pass, but the end is not yet.”
Don’t be deceived. We’re not losing it. What is past is prologue. And looking at our past I’d say our greatest days are still to come.
Of course it’s bullshit scaremongering.
(Though on the other hand, at least the survival supplies scaremongering you mention later is not entirely negative; while The Apocalypse ain’t likely coming, natural disasters do with some frequency.
And it’s nicer to have a big stash of supplies than not to.
Boy Scout motto and all that.)
I agree with having emergency staples at hand. But I don’t think people should live in constant fear.
I almost wish there would be an uprising of some kind. The population is mostly malcontent, yet we’ve been bred to a temper of non-confrontation. Forty, fifty years ago, people rallied and rioted and sat-in to get their voice out. Now people sit in front of their computer and update their Facebook status and imagine they’ve done something profound while the world outside their window rushes ever onward.
We should be more scared that most people AREN’T doing anything.
Of course it’s scare mongering bullshit. How else can they produce a culture of fear?
Scared people are easily convinced, easily controlled people. It’s just another tactic to sell you something – whether it’s a war, a new car seat for your baby, or a brand new car, the media go out of their way to terrify people.
Keeps them compliant. Boy I sound like a conspiracy nut. :v
Great post, and so well-written. Would that all the paid pundits said things as sensible, one could stand to listen to them!
Excellent post! Very insightful.
Well said, Steve.
A police officer I know once told me that a major factor in domestic abuse is, the husband lost his job. Unfortunately, many men feel defined by what they do, and once they lose that identity, they act out. These are difficult times, but let’s face it, the only reason these horrible incidents make the news is, they’re atypical.
This overall approach (to sit tight, it’s all going to be okay, brighter days are up ahead), that’s what you tell to an individual who is going through a hard time.
But nation should stand up and face its problems.
You people have a ridiculous monetary and banking system (look at the wealth gap!), you are engaged in two wars in three countries, all of which the popular media reports on minimally and the number of human beings killed are in the millions, your multi-nationals have divvied up 75% of Iraq’s oil amongst them and are taking over contracts to rebuild what bombs made with your tax dollars destroyed, and those are just the preliminary issues. And a lot of the national debt is because of those wars. The only people who profited are billionaires – some of whom have strong ties to your government. That is a searing indictment on the state of your democracy.
Sitting tight and hoping for better days is certainly sweet. And fear tactics are indeed terrible. But sometimes in life one has to stand up and take a look at what’s going on around them, take a stand and make a difference. Yes, the writer of that article is talking about a small manifestation of a much larger problem, and certainly there won’t be armies of people wandering around shooting things.
But it’s worth taking notice of the problems, not just dismiss this as a one-off.
The gun problem:
I wouldn’t pass the guns and angry people thing off as pandering to an agenda.
With the murder rate you people have, irate people with guns are ALREADY a huge problem in your country; and it’s not silly to think that when times are getting worse, when the system under which people have been living their lives starts to shake under them, one should take some precautions.
Your take on fearmongering reminds me of a term that this I.T. security guy coined: Security Theater.
Well said waiter, well said